= Blue Gate Favorite * = Available Sugar-Free
Blue Gate Home-Style Buffets
Prices: $12.49-24.99 | Children 4-11: $6.49-8.49Hours Vary by Day
Saturday Breakfast Buffet
Every Saturday - 7:00am - 10:30am
"All your Blue Gate favorites and some traditional Amish specialties, fresh and hot, and now with the selection of a buffet."
An incredible value and varied enough for every breakfast taste. Includes: Scrambled Eggs, Biscuits & Gravy, Cheesy Potatoes, Blue Gate Scramble, Hotcakes, French Toast, Fried Mush, Baked Cinnamon Apples, Tomato Gravy, Corned Beef Hash, Bread Pudding, (The Famous Blue Gate) Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Fresh Fruit, Fruit "Slush", Homemade Granola, Yogurt, Fresh Baked Pastries (Donuts, Breads Melt-in-your-Mouth Muffins).
Breakfast: $12.49 | Children 4-11: $6.49
Signature Lunch-Dinner Buffet
Lunch(Mon-Fri) (11:00a-3:00p)
Dinner (Mon-Wed) (3:00p-6:30p)
Come try our signature lunch and dinner buffet. Choose between selections of our famous Blue Gate Fried Chicken, Slow Cooked Roast Beef and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Lunch: $16.99 | Dinner: $17.99
Soup & Salad Bar: $12.99
BBQ Buffet
Every Thursday (3:00p-6:30p)
FEATURING: BBQ Pork Ribs, Pulled Pork, Roast Beef, Smoked Peppers and Sausage, Chicken, BBQ Meatballs, Mashed Potatoes, Cheesy Potatoes, Green Beans, Chicken Dressing, Baked Beans, Macaroni & Cheese, Homemade Noodles, Corn, BBQ Sauces, Gravy Grilled Pineapple, Rotating Hot Dessert and more!
This will also include our fresh Garden Bar, as well as our sweet and savory dessert bar featuring assorted pies, special desserts and much more.
19.99pp, Kids 7.99 (4-11)
Soup & Salad Bar: $12.99
Friday Dinner Buffet
Every Friday (3:00p-7:00p)
FEATURING: Our famous Blue Gate Fried Chicken, Roast Beef, Baked Swai with Butter Parmesan Sauce, Pollock Wings, Breaded Shrimp and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Dinner: $19.99
Soup & Salad Bar: $12.99
Saturday Buffet
Every Saturday (11:00a-7:30p)
FEATURING: Chicken, Smoked Ham, Shrimp, Meatloaf, Roasted Turkey, Roast Beef and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Dinner: $21.99
Soup & Salad Bar: $12.99
Daily and Seasonal Specials
Price Range: $11.99 - $14.99Today's Feature
Monday*
Amish Beef & Noodles
Locally sourced homemade noodles, cooked to a golden perfection with just the amount of seasonings and mouth watering roast beef. Served with real mashed potatoes and a garden salad. You will enjoy every bite! 12.99
Tuesday
Homestyle Meatloaf
Made from locally sourced ground beef that is antibiotic and hormone free. A hearty portion of freshly baked meatloaf topped with a sweet and savory glaze. Served with real mashed potatoes and corn. 14.49
Wednesday
Two Piece Chicken Dinner
Two pieces of fresh chicken, hand breaded and cooked under pressure, comes up tender and juicy. Served with mashed potatoes and noodles. 14.49
Thursday
Roast Smoked Ham
Our famous slow roasted smoked pulled ham, tender and delicous. Served with mashed potatoes and gravy and baked apples. 14.49
Blue Gate Lunch & Dinner Menu
Price Range: $3.49 - $19.99Starters
Onion Ring Tractor Stacker
A tower of thickly sliced onions coated in a country batter and fried to a golden brown. Served with ranch and honey mustard dipping sauce. 8.99
Choose between Farmall Red and John Deere Green.
Salads
Country Cobb Salad
Diced grilled chicken breast, bacon, and Monterey Jack cheese, diced egg, diced tomatoes, black olives, mushrooms, bleu cheese crumbles, peas and corn on mixed greens. Served with our famous French dressing. 14.99
Mandarin Orange Chicken Salad
This spectacular salad features spring greens, iceberg and romaine lettuce, grilled chicken breast, almonds, onions, cucumbers and dried cranberries. Colorfully topped with mandarin oranges and served with our very own made from scratch sweet vinegar and oil dressing. 13.49
Order without chicken for a great vegetarian option!
Strawberry Bacon Bleu
Fresh mixed greens topped with strips of tender chicken, fresh cut strawberries, diced bacon, candied pecans, and bleu cheese crumbles. Served with poppy seed dressing. (Seasonal) 14.99
BBQ Chicken Salad
Crisp mixed greens topped with sweet red onions, diced tomatoes, sweet corn, Monterey Jack cheese, and tender marinated chicken. Finished with a sweet BBQ drizzle, and served with a side of ranch dressing. 13.29
Blue Gate House Salad
Bed of mixed greens, topped with corn, peas, bacon bits, Monterey Jack cheese, eggs, olives, cucumbers, tomatoes & croutons. 12.99
Amish Platters
Amish Country Sampler
A sampling of our most popular menu items.
Features: our famous pressure-fried chicken, homestyle meatloaf, tender roast beef, mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, and a choice of corn or green beans.
- Also includes a garden salad. 16.99
Amish Door Casserole
Our famous roasted turkey, topped with our house made dressing and real mashed potatoes, ladled with a generous amount of gravy. Served with corn or green beans. 14.49
Manhattans
Tender roast beef, homestyle meatloaf, smoked pulled ham, or roasted turkey on homemade bread. Served with mashed potatoes and smothered with gravy. 12.99
Vegetarian Plate
Pick any four fresh country vegetable sides. 12.99
Amish Chicken and Noodles
Homemade noodles and chunks of chicken generously ladled over creamy real mashed potatoes. Includes choice of one side Full - 12.99 Half - 11.99
Country Kitchen Classics
Homestyle Meatloaf
We make our meatloaf from scratch just like Grandma used to make. Served as a hearty portion and topped with a special savory-sweet glaze. Served with your choice of two sides. 14.99
Our Famous Fried Chicken
Four pieces of our famous recipe chicken hand breaded and cooked under pressure until it comes up tender & juicy. Served with your choice of two sides. 4 Pieces - 15.99, 2 Pieces - 14.99, all white add 1.50
Country Roast Beef
We prepare this using an old-fashioned Amish recipe.
Slow roasted in the perfect seasonings, the end result is fork tender, melt-in-your-mouth goodness. Served with your choice of two sides. 14.99
Slow Roasted Smoked Ham
Our mouthwatering slow roasted smoked ham served with real mashed potatoes and gravy and baked apples. 14.99
Chicken and Biscuits
Open faced homestyle biscuits served with a side of real mashed potatoes and topped with a savory gravy chock-full of chunks of chicken, and fresh vegetables. Includes one side. 13.99
Monterey Chicken
A marinated chicken breast, topped with Monterey Jack cheese, diced tomatoes & scallions. Served with a side of hickory BBQ sauce and with two sides. 14.99
Roasted Turkey Dinner
Seasoned to perfection, this turkey is slow roasted in its natural juices, served with real mashed potatoes and gravy and homemade dressing. 14.99
Sandwiches Served with your choice of any one side.
Blue Gate B.L.T.
A generous helping of our famous Blue Gate bacon, crisp lettuce, and vine ripened tomatoes on fresh homemade toasted bread. 13.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich (seasonal)
Our house made recipe of chicken salad piled high on your choice of homemade white, wheat or sourdough toasted bread. 13.99
Meatloaf Sandwich
Love our famous delicious meatloaf? Enjoy it on homemade toasted sourdough bread. 14.49
French Dip Sandwich
Savory and thin sliced prime rib smothered in Swiss cheese & grilled onions. Served on a hoagie roll with au jus for dipping. 15.49
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Marinated chicken breast served on a hoagie roll with Swiss cheese, hearty tomatoes, lettuce, and mayo. 14.49
Add bacon 1.29
Blue Gate Club
Thinly sliced ham and turkey piled high on a fresh roll. Topped with bacon, cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, crisp lettuce, vine ripened tomatoes and finished with a creamy mayo. 14.99
Lighter Options
Mennonite Delight
A scoop of chicken salad, with a side of fresh seasonal fruit, cottage cheese, house-made potato salad and a garden salad. 13.49
Chicken Salad Plate
Our delicious recipe of chicken salad. Served on a bed of lettuce and with a side of tomato wedges. 4.99
Homemade Soups
Homemade Soups
For many years you've loved our home-style recipe soups... each one made from the freshest ingredients, with just the right spices for your enjoyment.
• Chicken & Noodle
• Creamy Potato
• Chef's Feature
Cup 3.99 • Bowl 4.99
The Best Local Ingredients!
At the Blue Gate you can always count on fresh, quality food. You may not know that a majority of our ingredients are grown right here in the Shipshewana area by local farmers! From the lettuce and tomatoes in your salad to the peaches in your pie, you'll find produce grown literally "down on the farm."
The produce isn't the only thing that we find locally; most of our delicious meats are from the area as well. We want to provide the best for our customers, which includes antibiotic and hormone free ground beef (used in our favorite meatloaf), as well as locally smoked and cured ham.
Not only is your meal coming straight from the farm, but we're also working on more MSG free items. And for our gluten free customers, we continue to develop more menu items especially for you. Ask your server to see our Special Dietary Menu.
Blue Gate Side Dishes
Blue Gate's Famous Family Style
Dinner: $20.99 – $25.49 | Kids: 4-11 $10.49, 0-3 Free
All you can eat.
"Experience a traditional Amish meal just like we serve in our homes, with the selection of a buffet, brought to your table in bowls and platters."
Tender roast beef, homemade meatloaf or turkey may be selected to accompany our famous fried chicken as your entrees. Your meal also includes real mashed potatoes, chicken dressing, gravy, vegetables, homemade bread and your choice of pie, bread pudding or ice cream and a beverage.
Please note: No carry-out with Family Style. Guests ordering Family Style are requested to do so for the entire party.
Blue Gate Kid's Menu
Menu Kid’s Meal: $6.99 | Kids Buffet $7.99 | Kids Buffet 0-3: Free
Children's Menu
Dinner
All kids lunch and dinner meals served with one side dish, milk or a soft-drink and a sugar cookie.
Choose: Chicken Drumsticks (2), Chicken & Noodles over Mashed Potatoes, Roast Beef or Smoked Ham, Chicken & Biscuits or Macaroni & Cheese.
Side Dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Noodles, Green Beans, Applesauce, Macaroni & Cheese, Mandarin Oranges, Side Salad, Corn
Blue Gate Desserts!
Price Range: Slices - $4.79-5.29 | Whole Pies - $15.49 - $17.49Try the pies that make us famous! They’re freshly made and baked to perfection. Choose a slice or take home a whole one.
Baked daily, sometimes we sell out, so order ahead for any special occasion: 260.768.4725
Year-Round Pie Options
Apple Pie*
Sliced apples cooked in their own juices, spiced with cinnamon and baked to a bubbly perfection.
Dutch Apple Pie
Fresh shredded apples covered in a glaze and topped with a cinnamon and sugar crumb topping.
Banana Cream Pie
A billowy whipped-cream topping conceals a velvety banana custard in this dreamy pie favorite.
Blueberry Pie*
Luscious ripe berries, cooked in our homemade filling overflow this lattice-crusted pie.
Fresh Blueberry Pie (Seasonal)
Juicy freshly picked berries crowd this flavorful pie topped with whipped cream.
Butterscotch Pie
An all time favorite... the custard is made from scratch recipe with caramelized sugar for that extra rich taste, like Grandma used to make.
Cherry Pie
Delicious red, tart cherries, juicy with that old-fashioned flavor.
Chocolate Pie
Every fork-full of this pie says chocolate, chocolate, chocolate.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut butter crumbs layered with chocolate and vanilla custard pudding and topped with whipped cream, more peanut butter crumbs and chocolate sprinkles.
Coconut Cream Pie
This tried and true, old fashioned coconut cream pie. The finest coconut folded into a creamy vanilla pudding gives it a perfect coconut flair.
German Chocolate Pie (Specialty)
This pie combines pecan and coconut, the ingredients everyone loves in its classic cousin 'the cake'. Now tastier than ever a creamy baked chocolate pie.
Lemon Meringue Pie
Slightly tart, slightly sweet, this pie is topped with a light and airy meringue.
Custard Pie
Made with Real cream and Real vanilla... our classic custard!
Old-Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie
Old fashioned Amish favorite, made from scratch with butter, brown sugar and cream and baked to a golden perfection. This pie will melt in your mouth.
Peach Pie*
Lots of tender juicy peaches piled in a flaky crust.
Peanut Butter Pie
Peanut butter blended with confectioners sugar and layered with vanilla custard pudding topped with whipped cream and peanut butter crumbs.
Pecan Pie (Specialty)
Good old-fashioned Pecan Pie. Plenty of buttery, caramelized pecan pieces go into the luscious filling.
Red Raspberry Cream Pie
Cream cheese and sour cream folded together and layered with vanilla custard pudding and red raspberries in a light glaze, with a whipped cream topping.
Cherry Crumb Pie
Our old fashioned cherry pie filling baked in the shell. Topped with a brown sugar, butter and oatmeal crumb topping. You'll think you're eating cobbler.
Lemon Cream Pie
This flavorful lemon pie is layered with cream cheese, our special lemon filling and whipped topping.
Seasonal Pies
Mincemeat Pie (Seasonal)
Fresh fruit and authentic ingredients just like Grandma's holiday pie steeped in tradition.
Fresh Peach Pie (Seasonal)
Summer's sweetest peaches with a light glaze and mounded on a freshly baked crust.
Srawberry Rhubarb Pie
Classic and delicious strawberry rhubarb pie recipe. Sweet fresh strawberries paired with tart rhubarb.
Rhubarb Pie (Seasonal)
The taste of tart, refreshing rhubarb with a custard base is the perfect combination for a spring pie.
Fresh Strawberry Pie (Seasonal)
Sweet ripe strawberries glisten under a light, flavorful glaze.
Cakes, Dumplings and more!
Homemade Fudge Brownie Mudslide
Delectable fudge brownie straight from the bakery warmed and then smothered in a warm velvety chocolate sauce and a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Apple Dumpling A la Mode
Warm, freshly baked apple dumpling served with a scoop of cinnamon ice cream and caramel sauce.
Mel's Classic Choice
A slice of old-fashioned sugar cream pie warmed & served with cinnamon ice cream.
Old-Fashioned Favorite
Old-Fashioned bread pudding warmed and served with ice cream.
Dark Chocolate Cake
Very moist and rich chocolate cake, a chocolate lover's dream.
Carrot Cake
Made from scratch and topped with cream cheese icing.
