= Blue Gate Favorite * = Available Sugar-Free
Blue Gate Home-Style Buffets
Prices: $13.99-24.99 | Children 4-11: $6.99-8.99Buffet Hours This Week: Mon-Wed - 11:00a-7:00p | Thu-Fri - 11:00a-7:30p | Sat - 7:00am-7:30pm
Breakfast Buffet (Saturdays)
"All your Blue Gate favorites and some traditional Amish specialties, fresh and hot, and now with the selection of a buffet."
An incredible value and varied enough for every breakfast taste. Includes: Scrambled Eggs, Biscuits & Gravy, Cheesy Potatoes, Blue Gate Scramble, Hotcakes, French Toast, Fried Mush, Baked Cinnamon Apples, Tomato Gravy, Corned Beef Hash, Bread Pudding, (The Famous Blue Gate) Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Fresh Fruit, Fruit "Slush", Homemade Granola, Yogurt, Fresh Baked Pastries (Donuts, Breads Melt-in-your-Mouth Muffins).
Breakfast: $13.99 | Children 4-11: $6.99
Signature Blue Gate Buffet
Come try our signature lunch and dinner buffet. Choose between selections of our famous Blue Gate Fried Chicken, Slow Cooked Roast Beef and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Dinner: $21.99
Soup & Salad Bar: $16.99
Children 4-11: $8.99
Weekend Buffet
Our signature dinner buffet with some extras! Choose between selections of our famous Blue Gate Fried Chicken, Slow Cooked Roast Beef and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, some extra, delicious, made from scratch family recipes!
This will also include our fresh Garden Bar, as well as our sweet and savory dessert bar featuring assorted pies, special desserts and much more.
Adult: $23.99pp
Soup & Salad Bar: $18.99
Children 4-11: $8.99
Friday Buffet
FEATURING: Our famous Blue Gate Fried Chicken, Roast Beef, Baked Swai with Butter Parmesan Sauce, Pollock Wings, Breaded Shrimp and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Adult: $23.99pp
Soup & Salad Bar: $18.99
Children 4-11: $8.99
Saturday Buffet
FEATURING: Chicken, Smoked Ham, Shrimp, Meatloaf, Roasted Turkey, Roast Beef and other Homestyle Amish Entrees. Enjoy many of your favorite homemade sides like Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Dressing, Homemade Noodles, Macaroni and Cheese, Green Beans, Corn, a soup & salad bar, as well as a large dessert bar. Plus, many other delicious made from scratch family recipes to choose from!
Adult: $23.99pp
Soup & Salad Bar: $18.99
Children 4-11: $8.99
Daily and Seasonal Specials
Price Range: $14.99 - $17.49Today's Feature
Monday
Amish Beef & Noodles
A Midwest comfort classic made from scratch with tender, slow-cooked roast beef and thick egg noodles from a local Amish supplier. Simmered to perfection in a rich, savory broth for a homestyle dish that tastes just like Sunday dinner. 16.49
Tuesday
Homestyle Meatloaf
Made from scratch just like Grandma used to make, this hearty meatloaf is topped with a savory-sweet glaze and served with real mashed potatoes and green beans. 16.99
Wednesday
Two Piece Chicken Dinner
Our famous chicken is marinated, hand breaded and cooked under pressure to lock in flavor and tenderness. Served with real mashed potatoes and noodles. 16.99
Thursday
Roast Smoked Ham
Our famous slow roasted smoked ham pulled from the bone, tender and delicious. Served with mashed potatoes and baked apples. 16.99
Friday
Cod Dinner
Premium Cod filets hand breaded and delicately seasoned. Then cooked to golden perfection. Served with hush puppies, fries and coleslaw.
Available from 4:00pm - close. 18.99
Saturday
Roasted Turkey Dinner
Seasoned to perfection, this turkey is slow cooked in its natural juices, leaving it fork tender. Served with mashed potatoes and homemade chicken dressing. Our guests ask for it over and over, showcasing why we don’t just serve it at Thanksgiving. 16.99
Blue Gate Lunch & Dinner Menu
Price Range: $4.29 - $18.99Starters
Onion Ring Tractor Stacker
A tower of thickly sliced onions coated in a country batter and fried to a golden brown. Served with ranch and honey mustard dipping sauce. 9.99
Choose between Farmall Red and John Deere Green.
Mozzarella Wedges
Crispy, golden mozzarella wedges served hot in our signature tractor puller—melty on the inside and perfectly crunchy on the outside. Comes with ranch dressing and savory marinara for dipping. 10.99
Farmhouse Fresh Salads Add a cup of soup for 3.29
Cobb Salad
A hearty mix of crisp greens topped with freshly grilled chicken, smoky bacon, Monterey Jack cheese, bleu cheese crumbles, chopped eggs, mushrooms, black olives, sweet peas, and corn. Served with our Famous House-made French dressing. 16.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
Crispy romaine lettuce tossed in creamy caesar dressing, topped with crunchy seasoned croutons and shaved parmesan cheese. Served with a grilled chicken breast. 15.49
Mandarin Orange Chicken Salad
This spectacular salad features spring greens, romaine lettuce, grilled chicken breast, almonds, onions, cucumbers and dried cranberries. Colorfully topped with mandarin oranges and served with raspberry vinaigrette or poppyseed dressing. 15.99
Order without chicken for a great vegetarian option!
Berry Bacon Bleu
Fresh mixed greens topped with tender diced chicken, fresh cut berries, diced bacon, candied pecans, and bleu cheese crumbles. Served with poppyseed dressing. (Seasonal). 16.49
BBQ Chicken Salad
Crisp greens with marinated grilled chicken, sweet corn, tomatoes, red onions, and Monterey Jack cheese, finished with a sweet and smoky BBQ drizzle. 15.99
Blue Gate House Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with garden-fresh cucumbers, ripe tomatoes, sweet peas, sliced eggs, savory bacon, black olives, and shredded Monterey Jack cheese. Served with your choice of dressing. 14.49
Add Chicken Breast - 2.50
Amish Platters
Amish Country Sampler
A sampling of our most popular menu items. Features: our famous pressure-fried chicken, homestyle meatloaf, tender roast beef, mashed potatoes, gravy, dressing, and a choice of corn, green beans, or noodles. Includes a garden salad. 18.99
Manhattans
Tender roast beef, homestyle meatloaf, smoked pulled ham, or roasted turkey on homemade bread. Served with mashed potatoes and smothered in gravy. 15.49
Meatloaf Shepherds Pie
Our famous Blue Gate Meatloaf served with a generous helping of real mashed potatoes and smothered with your choice of cheddar cheese sauce or beef gravy. Served with a side of corn. 16.49
Side Sampler
Choose any four of our signature homestyle sides to create your perfect meal. 14.49
Amish Chicken and Noodles
Homemade chicken and noodles served with a generous helping of real mashed potatoes and gravy. 15.49
Half 14.49 Includes choice of one side.
Grandma's Haystack
Our famous roasted turkey, topped with our house made chicken dressing and real mashed potatoes, ladled with a generous amount of gravy. Served with corn or green beans. 17.49
Hearty Homestyle Classics
Famous Fried Chicken
Our famous chicken is marinated, hand breaded and cooked under pressure until it comes up tender and juicy. Served with your choice of two sides. 17.99
All white add 1.50 Two pcs. 16.99
Homestyle Roast Beef
Prepared using an old-fashioned Amish recipe and slow-roasted in perfect seasonings until fork-tender and full of flavor. Served with your choice of two signature sides. 16.99
Monterey Chicken
Juicy grilled marinated chicken breast topped with melted Monterey Jack cheese, fresh diced tomatoes, and scallions. Served with BBQ sauce and your choice of two signature sides. 16.99
Homestyle Meatloaf
Made from scratch just like Grandma used to make, this hearty meatloaf is topped with a savory-sweet glaze and served with your choice of two signature sides. 16.99
Smoked Ham
Tender, slow-roasted smoked ham pulled from the bone and served warm with real mashed potatoes and baked apples. 16.99
Roasted Turkey Dinner
Seasoned to perfection, this turkey is slow roasted in its natural juices, served with real mashed potatoes and gravy and homemade chicken dressing. 16.99
Liver & Onions
A timeless comfort dish done the old-fashioned way. Tender slices of beef liver, lightly coated in our homemade seasoning blend and grilled to perfection. Topped with caramelized sautéed onions for rich, hearty flavor. Served with your choice of two sides. 16.49
Specialty Sandwiches Served with your choice of French Fries or Onion Rings | Sweet Potato Fries for 1.00 more
Blue Gate B.L.T.
A generous helping of our famous Blue Gate bacon, crisp lettuce, and vine ripened tomatoes. Served on fresh homemade toasted bread. 14.49
Grilled Meatloaf Sandwich
Love our famous delicious meatloaf? Why not enjoy it on homemade grilled sourdough bread as a sandwich. 14.99
French Dip Sandwich
Savory and thin sliced prime rib smothered in Swiss cheese & grilled onions. Served on a hoagie roll with au jus for dipping. 16.99
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Juicy, marinated grilled chicken breast served on a toasted brioche bun with Swiss cheese, crisp lettuce, ripe tomato, onions and tangy pickles. 15.99
Chicken Salad Croissant
A classic favorite made fresh with tender, shredded chicken, crisp celery, diced onions, and dill pickles, all blended in a creamy mayo dressing. Served on a buttery croissant with fresh lettuce for the perfect crunch in every bite. 14.99
Blue Gate Classic
One half pound grilled Angus beef patty, topped with American cheese. Served on a toasted bun with fresh lettuce, ripe tomato, and dill pickles. 16.49
Bacon Burger
Juicy half pound Angus beef patty, topped with American cheese, crispy bacon, and your choice of caramelized onion or onion rings. Finished off with a BBQ Sauce or Housemade Blue Gate sauce. 16.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, crisp romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan, and red onions, all tossed in creamy Caesar dressing and wrapped in a flour tortilla. 15.49
Mushroom and Swiss
One half pound juicy Angus grilled beef patty topped with melted Swiss cheese and sautéed mushrooms. Served on a toasted bun with fresh lettuce, ripe tomato and dill pickles. 16.49
Sourdough Melt
Half pound grilled Angus beef patty nestled between crispy sourdough, Swiss, and American cheese, with caramelized onions grilled to perfection. 16.49
Lighter Options
Mennonite Delight
A classic trio of creamy chicken salad, homemade potato salad and cottage cheese. Served with a fresh garden salad. 13.99
Chicken Salad Plate
Our delicious recipe of chicken salad. Served on a bed of lettuce and with a side of tomato wedges. 5.29
Add a cup of soup for 3.29
Soups
Soups
Chicken & Noodle and Vegetable Beef
Cup 4.29 Bowl 5.29
Signature Sides 3.99 ea.
Blue Gate Kid's Menu
Menu Kid’s Meal $8.99 | Kids Buffet: 4-11 (hours & price vary by day), 0-3 Free, Beverage .99 | Dine-in Only
Children's Menu
Dine in OnlyDinner
All kids lunch and dinner meals served with one side dish, milk or a soft-drink and a sugar cookie.
Choose: Chicken Drumsticks (2), Chicken & Noodles over Mashed Potatoes, Chicken Tenders (2), or Macaroni & Cheese.
Side Dishes: French Fries, Mashed Potatoes, Noodles, Green Beans, Applesauce, Macaroni & Cheese, Mandarin Oranges, Side Salad, Corn, Hush Puppies
Blue Gate Desserts!
Price Range: Slices - $4.99-5.49 | Whole Pies - $16.99 - $18.99Try the pies that make us famous! They’re freshly made and baked to perfection. Choose a slice or take home a whole one.
Baked daily, sometimes we sell out, so order ahead for any special occasion: 260.768.4725
Blue Gate Pie Selection
Try the pies that make us famous. They're freshly made and baked to perfection. Choose a slice or take home a whole one.
Apple Pie*
Sliced apples cooked in their own juices, spiced with cinnamon and baked to a bubbly perfection. Available in Sugar Free.
Dutch Apple Pie
Tender, spiced apples baked in a flaky, homemade crust and topped with a buttery cinnamon-sugar crumb topping that bakes to a golden finish. Warm, comforting, and perfectly sweet in every classic slice.
Banana Cream Pie
A dreamy classic featuring a velvety banana custard filling hidden beneath a billowy whipped cream topping. Smooth, creamy, and irresistible, it's a true favorite for banana lovers.
Blueberry Pie
Bursting with luscious, ripe blueberries in a sweet glaze, baked in a flaky lattice crust for a perfectly balanced blend of juicy fruit and classic comfort.
Butterscotch Pie
Velvety and rich, this pie features a house made butterscotch custard crafted with browned butter and dark brown sugar for a rich sweetness in a golden crust finished with a cloud of whipped cream.
Cherry Pie
Filled with delicious red tart cherries, juicy and bursting with sweet homemade flavor, all baked into a flaky, golden crust for a perfectly classic dessert.
Chocolate Cream Pie
Every fork-full of this pie says chocolate, chocolate, chocolate.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
Layers of peanut butter crumbs paired with smooth homemade chocolate and vanilla custard pudding; all topped with fluffy whipped cream. Finished with a sprinkle of peanut butter crumbs and chocolate sprinkles for a rich, sweet, and creamy indulgence.
Coconut Cream Pie
Tried and true, old fashioned coconut cream pie. The finest coconut folded into a creamy vanilla pudding gives it a perfect coconut flair.
German Chocolate Pie
Featuring the classic combination of pecans and coconut everyone loves, reimagined from its famous "cake" cousin. Rich, creamy, and baked into a smooth chocolate filling, this pie is tastier than ever and truly unforgettable.
Lemon Meringue Pie
A bright, tangy lemon filling nestled in a flaky homemade crust and topped with a cloud of fluffy, golden-browned meringue. A perfect balance of sweet, tart, and airy in every slice.
Custard Pie
Made from scratch just like Grandma used to make, this old-fashioned favorite features a smooth, creamy angel-like custard with a hint of vanilla, baked in a flaky homemade crust for a simple, timeless classic.
Old-Fashioned Sugar Cream Pie
Old fashioned Amish favorite, made from scratch with butter, brown sugar and cream, baked to a golden perfection. This pie will melt in your mouth.
Peach Pie
This homemade peach pie is a bit of summer paradise on a plate! Golden crust is filled with luscious sweet peach filling that is perfect with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Peanut Butter Pie
A peanut butter lovers dream, this home-made pie features a creamy peanut butter filling in a buttery crust, topped with a generous layer of peanut butter crumbs for a rich nutty finish.
Pecan Pie
Good old-fashioned pecan pie. Plenty of buttery caramelized pecan pieces go into this luscious homemade filling.
Red Raspberry Cream Pie
A luscious blend of cream cheese and sour cream folded together and layered with red raspberries in a light, sweet glaze and a smooth homemade vanilla custard pudding and topped off with a fluffy whipped cream topping for a bright, creamy dessert delight.
Cherry Crumb Pie
Juicy, tart cherries baked in a golden crust and topped with a buttery oatmeal crumb for the perfect balance of sweet and crunch.
Lemon Cream Pie
A luscious lemon custard over a layer of decadent cream cheese and topped with sweet and light whipped cream and a lemon glaze.
Seasonal Pies
Pecan Crunch Cream Pie
Featuring a light, creamy homemade butterscotch filling layered over sweet, candied pecans, all topped with a generous cloud of whipped cream for the perfect crunch-meets-cream bite.
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
A sweet-tart blend of ripe strawberries and tangy rhubarb baked into a golden crust, topped with a buttery streusel crumb. Bursting with bright flavor and rustic charm in every bite.
Rhubarb Crumb Custard Pie
A refreshing blend of tart rhubarb and smooth, creamy custard, baked into a flaky crust and finished with a buttery crumb topping-an irresistible taste of summer in every slice.
Fresh Blueberry Pie
Plump, juicy blueberries in a sweet homemade glaze, nestled in our flaky hand-pressed crust and layered with a smooth, creamy filling for a bright and refreshing dessert.
Key Lime Pie
Nothing satisfies quite like a true key lime. Sweet, rich, and creamy with the perfect touch of tang, this homemade classic melts in your mouth with every refreshing bite.
Mincemeat Pie
A traditional favorite filled with a rich blend of fruits, warm spices, and a hint of sweetness, all baked into our flaky homemade crust for a comforting, old-fashioned dessert.
Fresh Strawberry Pie
Sun-ripened strawberries tossed in a sweet glaze, nestled in our flaky homemade crust and finished with a generous dollop of whipped cream.
Pumpkin Pie
Savor the rich velvety blend of creamy pumpkin and warm spices, all nestled in a delicate, golden crust. The essence of autumn-comforting, nostalgic, and full of seasonal charm.
Favorite Desserts
Blue Gate Cheesecake
Love cheesecake? This creamy, made-from-scratch sensation is sure to satisfy. Smooth and rich with a subtle hint of lemon zest for a refreshing finish in every bite.
Amish Bread Pudding
A timeless, old-fashioned dessert just like Grandma used to make. Warm, soft, and tender with a sweet, custardy richness, served fresh from the oven with a scoop of ice cream for a comforting homemade treat.
Mel's Classic Choice
The dessert that started it all and remains a favorite of our founder. A warm slice of traditional sugar cream pie paired with smooth cinnamon ice cream creating a simple yet unforgettable combination of comfort and nostalgia in every bite.
Carrot Cake
Moist and flavorful, this Blue Gate favorite carrot cake is baked with fresh carrots and sweet pineapple for extra richness, generously iced with cream cheese icing.
Dark Chocolate Cake
An ultra-moist, rich, and decadent chocolate cake made for true chocolate lovers. Deep, intense cocoa flavor in every bite makes this dessert an irresistible dream come true.
Double Layer Coconut Cake
Soft, moist coconut cake layered with smooth house made custard and wrapped in a rich, creamy coconut icing. Topped with a hearty sprinkle of sweet coconut flakes for a decadent, tropical treat.
Ice Cream
Try a scoop of our Signature Cinnamon or Vanilla Ice Cream by adding a dip to any slice of warm fruit pie.
Amish Monster Cookie Indulgence
A warm homemade monster cookie bar topped with creamy vanilla ice cream, finished with rich chocolate sauce and our signature peanut butter spread. Served with a swirl of whipped cream for the perfect sweet indulgence.
Homemade Fudge Brownie Mudslide
Delectable fudge brownie straight from the bakery warmed and then smothered in a warm velvety chocolate sauce and a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Take Some Home!
The pies and baked goods that made us famous are ready to accompany you home. They're freshly made and baked to perfection. Since we bake them daily, we sometimes sell out, so order ahead. Perfect for any holiday or special occasion! Order your favorites online at BlueGateBakery.com.
Shipping now available across the USA!